Pros and Cons of Roman Style Pools
- mike
- Mar 19
- 4 min read
Roman-Style Inground Pools - Pros, Cons, and What Nobody Tells You
If you’ve been researching fiberglass pools, chances are you’ve come across the Roman-style design—especially models like the L36 from River Pools. And at first glance, it makes sense why people are drawn to it. It’s clean… symmetrical… timeless. But here’s the truth most pool companies won’t tell you:
A Roman-style pool is one of the most misunderstood pool shapes on the market.
So in this article, we’re going to break it all down—the good, the bad, and the stuff you’ll wish someone told you before you signed a contract.
What Is a Roman-Style Pool?
A Roman-style pool combines straight sides with rounded ends, giving you a hybrid between a rectangular and freeform pool. It’s structured—but softer. Classic—but still functional.
And models like the River Pools L36 take it a step further by adding features like:
A tanning ledge
A deep-end bench
A wide-open central swim space
Sounds pretty great, right? Well… yes—but only if it fits how you plan to use your pool.
The Pros of a Roman-Style Pool
1. Timeless, High-End Aesthetic
Roman pools have been around for centuries—and there’s a reason they haven’t gone anywhere.
They look expensive. They feel intentional. They fit just about any backyard style—from traditional Midwest homes to modern builds. If you want something that won’t look outdated in 10–15 years, this shape delivers.
2. A Balance Between Form and Function
Roman pools sit right in the middle:
More structured than freeform
More visually interesting than a rectangle
That balance is exactly why many homeowners choose them—they don’t feel too rigid or too organic.
3. Built-In Gathering Spaces (Social Layout)
One of the underrated strengths of a Roman pool—especially the L36—is how it naturally creates social zones:
Tanning ledge → kids, lounging, sun
Deep-end bench → conversation area
Open middle → play space
👉 It’s not just a pool—it’s a backyard hangout system.
4. Multiple Entry Points
Those rounded ends typically include steps or seating, which means:
Easier access for kids and older adults
More usable shallow areas
Better traffic flow when entertaining
5. Great for Relaxation-Focused Buyers
If your vision looks like:
Floating with a drink
Kids playing
Loungers on the ledge
Then a Roman pool absolutely shines.
And that’s exactly what the L36 was designed for—a mix of relaxation and light activity.
The Cons of a Roman-Style Pool
Now let’s talk about the part most sales conversations gloss over.
1. You Lose Usable Swim Space (This Is a Big One)
Here’s the reality: Those rounded ends?👉 They take up space.
So while a pool might be marketed as 16' x 36'…
You’re not getting 36 feet of straight swim lane
The true rectangular swim area is significantly shorter
👉 This is one of the biggest “surprises” buyers run into.
2. Not Ideal for Lap Swimming
If you’re thinking:“I want to swim laps every morning”
This is probably not your pool.
Why?
Steps and benches interrupt the lane
Rounded ends break your rhythm
Roman pools are built for recreation—not performance swimming.
3. Tanning Ledge = Even Less Swim Room
The L36 specifically includes a large tanning ledge.
That’s awesome… but:
👉 You’re trading swim space for lounging space
And depending on your priorities, that can either be:
A huge win
Or a long-term regret
4. Automatic Cover Limitations
Roman shapes can be more challenging when it comes to automatic covers:
Rounded ends complicate track systems
Some designs require customization or aren’t compatible
👉 If an auto cover is a must-have, this is something to address early.
5. Can Feel Smaller Than It Looks
This ties everything together:
Curved ends
Built-in features
Tanning ledge
👉 All of it eats into open water.
And many homeowners say:
“I thought it would feel bigger.”
6. Less Flexibility (Fiberglass Reality)
With fiberglass pools like the L36:
You’re choosing from a fixed mold
No custom length/width adjustments
So if the size is almost right… it’s still your only option.
So… Who Is a Roman Pool (Like the L36) Actually For?
✅ Great Fit If You:
Want a visually striking, timeless design
Care more about relaxation than exercise
Love tanning ledges and social spaces
Entertain often
❌ Not a Great Fit If You:
Want a true swim lane
Need to maximize every inch of water space
Have a tight backyard
Require a simple automatic cover setup
The Moral of the Story
Here’s the bottom line:
👉 A Roman-style pool like the L36 is not about maximizing space👉 It’s about maximizing experience
It’s built for:
Conversations
Lounging
Family time
Not:
Lap swimming
Pure efficiency
Automatic Pool Cover Friendly
And if you go into the decision understanding that? You’ll probably love it.
If you don’t… You may wish you had gone rectangular.
SHAMELESS CALL TO ACTION
If you are ready to dive in and explore the possibilities of fiberglass pool ownership don't hesitate to call Pool Pros today @ 920-771-0107 or click here. Our in house pool designers are waiting to help create the outdoor living area of your dreams. When Quality Counts, Count on Pool Pros.
AUTHOR BIO
Mike Bowers is the founder and owner of Pool Pros Inc. in Green Bay, Wisconsin. He has spent 29 years installing and servicing swimming pools throughout Northeast Wisconsin. Is an Advanced Certified Building Professional, Certified Service Professional, Licensed General Contractor, Father to 4 beautiful children and Husband to the one and only "PoolWife" Lysti.
HELPFUL LINKS
